It’s one of the most common questions we hear from buyers moving to or within Tampa: “Is new construction really more expensive than buying a resale home?”
The short answer? It depends.
The long answer—and the one that actually helps you make a smart decision—comes down to understanding price, long-term value, lifestyle, and the Tampa market itself.
With over 40+ years of combined experience helping buyers, sellers, and investors navigate Tampa real estate, we’ve seen this question evolve with the market. Let’s break it down the way we do with our own clients.
Sticker Price: New Construction vs. Resale
On paper, new construction homes in Tampa often come with a higher purchase price than resale properties. Builders factor in rising land costs, materials, labor, and modern design features—open floor plans, energy-efficient systems, impact windows, and smart home technology.
Resale homes, especially those built 10–30 years ago, can appear more affordable upfront. They’re often in established neighborhoods with mature landscaping and closer proximity to downtown Tampa, South Tampa, or the beaches.
But here’s where buyers need to look deeper.
The Hidden Costs Buyers Overlook
A resale home may have a lower price tag, but maintenance and upgrades can add up quickly. Roofs, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical, and insurance costs can surprise buyers who focus only on list price.
New construction, on the other hand, typically offers:
-
Builder warranties
-
Brand-new roofs, systems, and appliances
-
Lower insurance premiums
-
Better energy efficiency (which matters in Florida heat)
In many cases, we’ve seen buyers spend tens of thousands within the first few years on a resale—costs they didn’t anticipate at closing.
Location Matters—A Lot
One major factor driving the price difference is where new construction is located.
In Tampa, new builds are often found in:
-
Wesley Chapel
-
Riverview
-
Land O’ Lakes
-
Apollo Beach
-
Parts of Brandon and Lutz
These areas offer newer communities, amenities, and space—but longer commutes.
Resale homes dominate in:
-
South Tampa
-
Seminole Heights
-
Hyde Park
-
St. Pete and surrounding areas
If being close to work, dining, nightlife, or the water matters, resale homes may offer better value for your lifestyle, even if they require updates.
What About Builder Incentives?
This is where working with experienced local agents makes a huge difference.
Many buyers don’t realize that builders often offer incentives:
-
Closing cost credits
-
Rate buy-downs
-
Design upgrades
-
Price reductions (especially toward quarter-end)
Emeri and Joe regularly negotiate these incentives for our clients—sometimes making a new construction home comparable or even more affordable monthly than a resale purchase.
Investors: Which Makes More Sense?
For investors, the decision depends on strategy.
-
New construction can be appealing for lower maintenance, higher rents, and strong tenant demand.
-
Resale homes often provide better cash flow upfront, especially if purchased below market value or renovated strategically.
Tampa’s rental demand remains strong, but the right choice depends on location, HOA rules, and exit strategy. This is where local insight truly matters.
So… Is New Construction More Expensive?
Not always—and not in the ways that matter most.
New construction may cost more upfront, but resale homes can cost more over time. The right choice depends on:
-
Your budget
-
Timeline
-
Lifestyle needs
-
Long-term goals
As Tampa real estate experts who live and work in this market every day, our job is to help you see beyond the listing price and make a decision that actually works for you.
If you’re weighing new construction versus resale—or just want honest advice tailored to your situation—Emeri and Joe Lewkowicz are here to help. Tampa is a nuanced market, and having the right guidance can make all the difference.
Let’s talk through your options and find the best fit for your next move.
